The Use of Bills of Exchange Worldwide

The bill of exchange is a fundamental financial instrument in international trade and finance, facilitating transactions and providing a secure method for payments. Its use varies significantly across different legal systems, including common law and civil law countries, each with its own regulatory framework and practical applications.

Bills of Exchange in Common Law Countries

1. United States
In the United States, bills of exchange are regulated by the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC). They are referred to as drafts, and their usage is common in both domestic and international trade. The UCC provides a comprehensive set of rules that govern the creation, endorsement, and enforcement of drafts.

Example:
A U.S. exporter sells goods to a European importer. To secure payment, the exporter issues a bill of exchange (draft), which the importer accepts. The draft stipulates that the importer will pay a specified amount on a future date. This instrument is then either held by the exporter until maturity or sold to a financial institution at a discount.

2. United Kingdom
In the UK, bills of exchange are governed by the Bills of Exchange Act 1882. This Act outlines the form, negotiation, and enforcement of bills of exchange, providing a clear legal framework that has influenced many other common law jurisdictions.

Example:
A British supplier delivers machinery to an African buyer. The supplier draws a bill of exchange on the buyer, who accepts it, promising to pay the specified amount within 90 days. The bill can be discounted with a bank, providing immediate cash flow to the supplier.

Bills of Exchange in Civil Law Countries

1. Germany
In Germany, bills of exchange are regulated by the Wechselgesetz (German Bills of Exchange Act). The law is detailed and provides strict formal requirements for the validity and enforceability of bills of exchange.

Example:
A German manufacturer exports vehicles to a South American company. The manufacturer draws a bill of exchange on the buyer, who accepts it. The bill specifies that payment is due 60 days after sight. The manufacturer can then use the bill to secure financing from a German bank.

2. France
In France, the use of bills of exchange is governed by the Code de Commerce. French law also imposes strict formal requirements and provides for various mechanisms of enforcement, including summary procedures for unpaid bills.

Example:
A French wine producer exports to a Canadian distributor. The producer draws a bill of exchange, and the distributor accepts it, agreeing to pay 30 days after the bill’s issuance. The producer can then endorse the bill to a financial institution for early payment.

Comparison: Common Law vs. Civil Law Countries

Formal Requirements

• Common Law: Generally, fewer formal requirements. Flexibility in terms of form and content.
• Civil Law: Strict formal requirements. Detailed specifications for the form, content, and endorsement of bills.

Enforcement

• Common Law: Emphasis on the parties’ intent and the bill’s function in commercial transactions.
• Civil Law: Emphasis on compliance with formal requirements. Detailed procedures for enforcement.

Transferability

• Common Law: Highly transferable. Endorsement practices are flexible.
• Civil Law: Transferability is subject to strict formalities. Endorsements must comply with specific legal requirements.

Bills of Exchange in Brazil

In Brazil, bills of exchange are primarily regulated by the Civil Code (Law No. 10,406/2002) and the Law of Uniform Bills of Exchange and Promissory Notes (Decree No. 57,663/1966). The Brazilian legal framework is influenced by both civil law traditions and international conventions.

Key Features of Brazilian Bills of Exchange

• Formal Requirements: Brazilian law mandates specific formal requirements for a bill of exchange to be valid. These include the date and place of issuance, the signature of the drawer, the name of the drawee, and the payment terms.
• Endorsement and Transfer: Bills of exchange can be transferred through endorsement. Each endorsement must be dated and signed, and Brazilian law strictly regulates the transfer process to ensure the bill’s integrity.
• Enforcement: The enforcement of bills of exchange in Brazil is straightforward, following the procedures outlined in the Code of Civil Procedure. Unpaid bills can be enforced through judicial proceedings, and creditors can seek measures such as asset seizure or wage garnishment.

Example:
A Brazilian coffee exporter sells goods to a Japanese importer. The exporter draws a bill of exchange on the importer, who accepts it, agreeing to pay within 60 days. The exporter can then endorse the bill to a Brazilian bank, receiving immediate payment. If the importer fails to pay, the bank can enforce the bill through the Brazilian courts.

Conclusion

The use of bills of exchange varies significantly between common law and civil law countries, reflecting their distinct legal traditions and regulatory frameworks. In common law countries like the United States and the United Kingdom, the emphasis is on the parties’ intent and the practical utility of the bill. In civil law countries such as Germany and France, strict formal requirements and detailed enforcement mechanisms prevail.

Brazil, influenced by civil law traditions, provides a robust legal framework for the use of bills of exchange. The strict formal requirements and well-defined enforcement procedures ensure that bills of exchange are a reliable tool for international trade and finance. Understanding these differences is crucial for legal professionals and business entities engaged in international transactions, ensuring secure and efficient financial operations.

Raphael da Fonsêca Ferreira de Souza
Lawyer specialized in Comparative Law and Negotiable Instruments

I hope this article is useful and informative. If you have any questions or need more information, please do not hesitate to contact me!